Manny's Tree ServiceManny's Tree ServiceTulsa, Oklahoma
ServicesTree RemovalTree TrimmingPruning & ToppingStump GrindingEmergency Storm DamageFence Line & Vine ClearingConcrete RemovalJunk RemovalService AreasTulsaEast TulsaBroken ArrowCowetaOwassoSand SpringsCollinsvilleSkiatookBartlesvilleJenksGlenpoolMuskogeeMoreReviewsGuidesAboutContactCall (918) 296-4184

Is topping a tree bad for it?

Yes. Topping a tree — cutting the main stems back to stubs to make the whole tree shorter — is bad for it, and it usually makes the exact problem it was meant to fix worse. The tree responds to losing its crown by pushing a dense cluster of fast, weakly attached shoots from just under each cut, so within a few years it is taller than it was, bushier than it was, and holding that new weight on attachments that were never structural. Proper crown reduction, where each limb is cut back to a living lateral branch large enough to take over, gets you a shorter tree without any of that.

The short version: height can be reduced. It just cannot be reduced with a flat cut across the top.

What actually happens to a topped tree

Four things, in order:

  • The wound does not close. A cut made in the middle of a limb, with no lateral branch below it to draw sap past the cut, has nothing to seal to. It sits open and dries out.
  • Decay moves down the stem. Open stubs let water and fungi into heartwood. Years later the tree looks fine from the street and is hollow where it was cut.
  • Regrowth comes back wrong. The shoots that replace the crown are attached to the outer layers of wood, not anchored deep in it. They grow fast, get long, and snap.
  • The tree runs short on food. Removing most of the leaf area at once removes most of the tree's ability to feed itself, right when it needs stored energy to recover.

That last point is why a topped tree often declines for two or three seasons and then dies while looking like it was recovering.

Why does anyone top a tree?

Usually for a real reason that has a better solution. The honest reasons people ask for it:

  • The tree is too tall and feels dangerous
  • Limbs are over the roof, the pool, or the power service drop
  • It blocks light or a view
  • It dropped a limb last storm and the owner wants the risk gone

Every one of those is addressable. None of them requires topping. Reduction, selective thinning, clearance pruning, and in some cases removal and replanting each solve one of them properly.

What should be done instead?

Crown reduction. Each stem is shortened back to a living side branch that is at least about a third the diameter of what is being removed, so there is a real branch left to take over the flow. The tree ends up shorter, the cuts can close, and the structure stays sound.

Selective thinning. Removing some branches entirely, back to their origin, reduces wind sail and weight without shortening the tree. On a dense canopy this often gets more storm benefit than reduction does.

End-weight reduction. The most useful single thing on many metro trees. The failure mode in a wind event is usually a long limb with all its weight far out at the tip. Shortening those tips back to good laterals takes the leverage out.

Deadwooding. Dead limbs are what come down first. Taking them out is low-impact work and can be done in any season.

Removal, sometimes. A tree that is hollow, mostly dead, or structurally failed is not a candidate for pruning. Paying to prune a tree that is coming out in two years is the most expensive option on the list.

The one case where stubs are not malpractice

Storm response. When a tree has already been broken, the crew's first job is to get the hazard down and the site safe, and that sometimes means cuts that are not final. Those are temporary. The follow-up visit, in the next dormant season, is where the remaining structure gets cleaned up to proper cuts. Manny's Tree Service treats that as two jobs rather than calling a storm cut finished work.

Pollarding and some utility line clearance also involve repeated heading cuts, but those are specific systems started on young trees and maintained on a cycle. They are not the same as taking a chainsaw across the top of a mature shade tree once.

Which trees around here get topped most, and what it does to them

  • Bradford pear. Already known for splitting at the crotch because of how tightly its limbs are attached. Topping one adds a crown of fast shoots above that weak union, which is the worst possible load to put on it.
  • Silver maple. Fast-growing and weak-wooded to begin with. A topped silver maple regrows faster than almost anything else in a Tulsa-area yard and the regrowth is brittle.
  • Hackberry. Responds to topping with a thicket of shoots and a lot of new deadwood a few years later.
  • Pin oak and post oak. Besides the structural damage, topping an oak in the growing season is also the wrong time for it, since oaks are generally pruned in the dormant season to avoid oak wilt risk.

Oklahoma gets strong spring storms with straight-line wind and hail, and the December 2007 and October 2020 ice storms both caused very widespread limb and tree damage across the Tulsa area. Topped trees carrying five or ten years of weak regrowth are the ones that come apart in those events.

In Owasso, the usual version of this question

Across Owasso the call is often about a landscape tree that has grown past the house it was planted next to — a maple or a pear that is now taller than the roof, with limbs reaching over shingles and a service drop in the way. The owner has been told the fix is to cut the top out. It usually is not. On most of those trees the real list is three long limbs reduced back to laterals, the deadwood out, and five feet of clearance over the roof, which costs less than topping and does not start a decline.

How to say no to it without losing the height you wanted

Ask any company that proposes topping two questions. Where will each cut land, and what lateral branch is left to take over? If the answer is a specific branch on each stem, that is reduction and it is fine. If the answer is a height — "we'll take ten feet off the top" — that is topping.

Manny's Tree Service writes free estimates on site, limb by limb, so the plan is readable before anyone starts cutting. For pruning and topping work done as proper reduction, call (918) 296-4184.

Need this done rather than read about? Manny's Tree Service quotes it free and on site across the Tulsa metro, Mon–Sat, 8am–6pm, plus emergency calls any hour. Call (918) 296-4184
FAQ

Related questions

Is topping a tree ever acceptable?

Manny's Tree Service does not top healthy mature trees, because the stub cuts cannot close and the regrowth is weakly attached. The exception is storm response, where a temporary cut gets a hazard down safely and is cleaned up to a proper cut on a follow-up visit.

Can a tree be made shorter without topping it?

Yes. Manny's Tree Service reduces height by cutting each stem back to a living lateral branch big enough to take over, which lowers the tree while leaving sound structure and cuts that can seal.

What happens to a tree that has already been topped?

Manny's Tree Service inspects topped trees for decay at the old cuts and for weakly attached regrowth above them. Some can be put on a restoration plan over several dormant seasons, and some are far enough gone that removal is the honest recommendation.

How much does crown reduction cost in the Tulsa area?

Manny's Tree Service prices trimming and pruning on site, because the size of the tree and the access to it drive the number. Estimates are free and done on site at (918) 296-4184.

That tree isn't getting smaller

Free estimate, firm price, yard left clean. Call Manny's Tree Service and get it off the list.

Call NowFree Estimate